Home › Solutions › Abstract management software › Abstract review

Klobbi Abstract · Steps 2 and 3: review and decide

Abstract review software for scientific committees

Abstract review software gives each reviewer a queue of the abstracts assigned to them and a scoring form built on the committee's criteria. In Klobbi Abstract, reviewers see only their own categories with author names hidden, and the committee sees every score as it arrives, ranked and ready for a decision.

★★★★★ Trusted by 5000+ events, including government agencies, universities and corporate conferences · ISO/IEC 27001 certified · CSA Cyber Trust mark

A clinician working at a desktop computer in an office, as a reviewer might when scoring abstracts

Figure 1. A reviewer works through their own queue of abstracts. Photo: Freepik.

Each reviewer sees only their categories

Each reviewer is assigned one or more categories. Submissions in those categories go to them automatically, and everything outside them is simply not in their account. A reviewer scoring imaging abstracts never scrolls past the heart-failure submissions, and nobody gets the whole pile.

Blind review

Author names and affiliations are hidden from reviewers.

A queue, not an inbox

Each reviewer sees their assigned abstracts, what's done, what's left and when the review window closes.

Reviewer portal in Klobbi Abstract: a queue of Cardiac Imaging abstracts with author names hidden (demo data)

Figure 2. A reviewer's queue: one category, author names hidden. Klobbi Abstract demo with sample data.

Example rubric

How a reviewer scores one abstract

Originality

4

Method

3

Relevance

4

Clarity

5

Figure 3. How a reviewer scores one abstract: each criterion gets a numeric score, plus a comment the author will see. Example only: your committee sets its own criteria.

Scored against your criteria

Reviewers give a numeric score for each of your criteria and add a comment the author will see. Use the criteria your committee already works with.

Scores in real time

Scores, votes and comments appear as reviewers submit them, with no collation spreadsheet.

Progress you can follow

The chair sees progress per reviewer and per category while reviews are still coming in.

Reminders before the window closes

Scheduled reminders go to reviewers before the review window ends.

Ranked, decided and sent together

When the reviews are in, the committee works from a ranking: every abstract with its average and each reviewer's score, in each category. Accept or decline each one. The decisions go out together, so no presenter hears before another.

Email

Confirmation

Accepted presenters get a confirmation with a link back to their portal, where the presenter ticket is now open.

Email

Declination

Declined presenters get a declination carrying the reviewers' comments.

Both email templates are yours to edit. After the decisions, accepted presenters move on to presenter management.

Committee dashboard in Klobbi Abstract with submissions, reviews, decisions and registrations (demo data)

Figure 4. The committee dashboard: submissions, reviews and decisions in one view. Klobbi Abstract demo with sample data.

Single-blind, double-blind and open review

Committees use different review models. This is what each one means.

Review model

Reviewers know the authors

Authors know the reviewers

Single-blind

Yes

No

Double-blind

No

No

Open review

Yes

Yes

In Klobbi Abstract, author names and affiliations are hidden from reviewers. Tell us which model your committee uses and we'll confirm the set-up before your call opens.

Abstract review: questions

Can we use our own scoring criteria?

Yes. Reviewers give a numeric score for each of your committee's criteria, plus a comment the author will see.

Do authors see the reviewers' comments?

Declined presenters receive a declination email carrying the reviewers' comments, so reviewers write their comments for the author.

Show your committee how review works

Send us your categories, the number of reviewers and the criteria your committee uses. We'll show you the reviewer queue and the committee ranking on a call, and reply with a quote within one working day.

WhatsApp +65 8836 2597 Email sales@klobbi.com

By sending this form, you agree that Klobbi may use these details to reply to your enquiry, as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Thanks. We’ve got your enquiry and will reply within one working day.